Skip to main content

How Case Studies Win the Work

Bre Corn|

Our case studies remember the work. The best ones win the next one.

This summer I read almost every case study in our sales deck. Over 175 of them. Nobody asked me to read them for fun; I was building a database for the team to help launch our new website.

I expected this to only be a cleanup project. What I got instead was a crash course in Viget history: clients who stuck with us for six years, products we helped launch, and small engagements that grew into decade-long relationships. After reading about 60 of them, I realized our case studies are the closest thing we have to a company scrapbook.

That’s the good news. It’s also the problem.

Not every project makes the scrapbook

Some projects get the full treatment: a polished write-up, a slide in the sales deck, and a page on viget.com. Other projects wrap up, the team heads straight into the next kickoff, and nobody circles back. No write-up, no slide, no page. The work was great, but didn’t make it into the book.

And what doesn’t make the book fades away. The people who did the work move on to other projects, sometimes other companies, and the details leave with them. 

A year later, a potential client might come along with the exact problem we solved previously and ask, “Has Viget done this before?” We have, but we have nothing to show for it. As far as they’re concerned, if it isn’t in the scrapbook, it didn’t happen.

So, what actually loses deals?

Budget and timing might seem like the most obvious reasons we lose deals, but they aren’t. We went back through a chunk of our closed pipeline, wins and losses, and the pattern was actually project fit. When we lost, the prospective team told us they didn’t see themselves in our work.

That gives the case study a very specific job: showing that we’ve been in this situation, with this kind of audience, before anyone gets on a call. Proving that we can be an effective partner for solving their problem answers a question before they’ve asked.

The right examples can open the door

Prospective clients sort agencies by relevance first. A policy nonprofit told us on an intro call that the first thing they’d look at was our work for organizations like theirs: NGOs, think tanks, and government-adjacent groups. A portfolio full of corporate sites might suggest we don’t understand their world. 

We flipped through our scrapbook to consider how our work might look to them. One project fit, but it was dated and an example of a design-only project, which isn’t much to build a pitch on. We knew we could do the work, but we just couldn’t prove it.

Clients are looking for the perfect match

The right examples get us into the room. When a potential client flips through our case studies and spots their own problem, the conversation changes. They stop asking whether we can do it and start asking how we’d do it for them. Every match is one less leap of faith a potential client has to take before saying yes to working with us.

A crisp, scannable case study says we sweat the details before they ever see us work on their project. The trick is putting the polish on the right things. If we can make the problem, the tradeoffs, and what changed easy for prospective clients to find, and the story will almost sell itself.

Three shifts we’re testing

  1. Write it before you need it. Make the case study part of the sales process, not an afterthought. When a project wraps, the case study starts. It goes into our sales slides, then onto viget.com, and the proof exists before the next prospect asks for it.
  2. Lead with the problem. Open every case study with the problem the client walked in with. The client name and timeline can wait their turn.
  3. Organize by problems solved. Build the index around problems, not services. That’s how prospective clients search, and it’s how referral sources describe us to other people.

Keep crafting the scrapbook

We are evolving the scrapbook over time. Reading 175 case studies taught me more about how we work with clients than the new hire onboarding process did, so I know these have value for future hires. Most importantly, the content needs to be geared toward someone deciding whether to trust us with their problem. Every page is a chance to make that connection and each one should be ready to do its job. The next time a prospective client asks, “Have you done something like this before?” I want us to have a great answer.

Budget and timing might seem like the most obvious reasons we lose deals, but they aren’t. We went back through a chunk of our closed pipeline, wins and losses, and the pattern was actually project fit. When we lost, the prospective team told us they didn’t see themselves in our work.

That gives the case study a very specific job: showing that we’ve been in this situation, with this kind of audience, before anyone gets on a call. We want to prove that we can be an effective partner for solving their problem before they’ve even had a chance to ask.

The right examples get us into the room. When a potential client flips through our case studies and spots their own problem, the conversation changes. They stop asking whether we can do it and start asking how we’d do it for them. Every match is one less leap of faith a potential client has to take before saying yes to working with us.

A crisp, scannable case study says we sweat the details. The trick is putting the polish on the right things. If we can make the problem, the tradeoffs, and what changed easy for prospective clients to find, and the story will almost sell itself.

We are evolving the scrapbook over time. Reading 175 case studies taught me more about how we work with clients than the new hire onboarding process did, so I know these have value for future hires. More importantly, the content needs to be geared toward someone deciding whether to trust us with their problem. Every page is a chance to make that connection and each one should be ready to do its job. The next time a prospective client asks, “Have you done something like this before?” I want us to have a great answer.

← Drag →